But, this smoky, peated, flavorful whisky comes from BenRiach up in Speyside. With this aim, we asked some of our favorite bartenders to share the most overrated Scotches on the market. For more information, please see our Taste Test: Forget Jack Daniels. I wouldnt mind trying the 12 cask strength if it wasnt so overpriced. 275 Bruichladdich Octomore 7.1 Scottish Barley 25 ml 570 Bunnahabhain 12yo 25 ml 270 Laphroaig 10yo 25 ml 285 Ardbeg 10yo 25 ml 255 Ardbeg Wee Beastie 25 ml 230 Ardbeg Uigeadail 25 ml 390 . Naysayers say that its like drinking an ashtray or that it smells like a tire store. Next on my list to try will be either Bunnahabhain 12 or Glendronach 12. ); I included the 18 in my Top 10 whiskies of 2016 list. Flavor is rich, with a deliciousblast of smoke, caramel, along fruity sweetness. Next to Bruichladdichs Octomores, Ardbeg has the peatiest whiskies in all of Scotland, as measured by phenol parts per million. Its a weird combination, but a very tasty one. Ardbeg 10 - 41.95 ($56): Where Lagavulin's smoky element is meaty, and Laphroaig's more medicinal, Ardbeg's is earthy. Once you come to terms with it you will find a hard time enjoying traditional Scotch whiskies. Ardbeg is slightly less medicinal than Laphroaig, however, it is more balanced and complex. If youre using it for anything other than a float on a penicillin, youre wasting everyones time. The Ardbeg is drinkable and delicious and invites you back time after time. Heres Our Review Of Cocaine Bear: Oh Hell Yes! There are better, less peat-driven Scotches from Islay that I certainly prefer. Is this better than the Ardbeg 10? But both brands offer various spirits, such as: Note: The Laphroaig 10 has won the Gold Medal at the 2019 Worlds Spirits Competition (San Francisco) and was recognized as 2019s Best Single Malt Scotch 10 Years & Under by Jim Murrays Whisky Bible. Bruichladdich Black Art- 288 ($381): Whisky geeks go nuts for thevarious editions of the Black Art - production and maturation of which remains a secret - but I dont think Ive ever tried one that really impressed me, or was worth the money. A favorite of bartenders and scotch fans alike, Caol Ila 12 is well-known as one of the best smoky/briny Islay whisky gateway bottles. Do they not have similar flavor profiles? Another Islay legend is the Ardbeg and the passion for Ardbeg reaches fever pitch all over the world on Ardbeg Day. A gorgeous rebuttal to all the naysayers who claim extra-aged whiskies are nothing more than marketing tools. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. When it comes to peaty, smoky Scotch whiskies, no list is complete without the godfather of all smoke bombs, Octomore. In this in-depth comparison, well discuss the various differences between Laphroaig vs Ardbeg to see which spirit deserves your recognition. In fact, back then it was the oldest expression ever. But both brands offer various spirits, such as: Required fields are marked *. The long aging period diminished the smoky notes a bit whilst adding the sweet vanilla from the bourbon barrels. It is a lighter expression with the right amount of smokiness and quality. As for Lagavulin, along with the malted barley are peat and water from Solan Lochs, sourced from west of the Islay island (where Caol Ila and Port Charlotte Distillery lies). It all ends in a dry, pleasingly warm, smoky finish. After all, it's all personal preference. I'd give each roughly high 70s, maybe an 80. Nose is full of smoke, ash and coal but mellows out into a rich caramel scent as you let it develop. Salz und Gewrze Hochwertige Salze, Gewrze oder Gewrzmischungen fr beste Kocherlebnisse. Bottles from both are a great way to start appreciating smoky whiskies. - Winehelp Lagavulin malt 16 years old 16 43,0% 700 . Perhaps Marc P can organise. I belong in the former. Here is a good starter for the weekend. I'd say Lagavulin 8, Talisker 10, Bruichladdich Port Charlotte 10, Ardbeg 10 or An Oa (some poo-poo the An Oa, but I find it a nice change of + View Here. Yes, it is peaty with smoke and fruity sweetness but lacks the complexity and wow factor. The expression was distilled using Publican and Optic barley that was grown at Kilchoman and malted and peated on location. As the sage Jay-Z says, Its not a diss song, its just a real song., One of the best #macallan #macallan18 #themacallan #themacallan18 #whisky #nyc #nycdrinks #thebest #whiskys, A post shared by ULYSSESG (@ulyssesgardoqui) on May 7, 2020 at 5:17pm PDT, Jeremy Allen, beverage director of MiniBar Hollywood in Los Angeles. It all ends with a nice, spicy, warming smoky heat. - WineStyle! Lowland whiskies tend to be sweeter with more pronounced caramel flavors. Take a few moments to breathe in the scents of cinnamon apples, sea salt, dried fruits, and dried peat. The finish is dry, warming, and ends with a nice combination of vanilla, smoke, and brine. Lagavulin/Laphroaig/BenRiach/Bruichladdich/iStock/Uproxx, Ten Great Single Malt Whiskies For Fans of Smoke, GloRilla, Ice Spice, And The Carefree Black Girl Backlash, Karol G Tells Us About Her Most Personal Album Yet, Maana Ser Bonito, And Collaborating With Shakira, The Rundown: Between Cocaine Bears And Maple Syrup Heists, Margo Martindale Is Absolutely Thriving In 2023. Other notable whisky expressions include the 12-Year-Old Cask Strength, the 2006 Distillers Edition, the 8-Year-Old 200th Anniversary Edition, and the original 8-Year-Old whisky. During the time of Prohibition, this was one of the few legally imported Islay whiskies into the US due to its medicinal notes. They aren't as heavy, oily and brooding as a Lagavulin nor are they as light and crisp as Ardbeg; they inhabit that pleasant middle ground where everything comes together in wonderful harmony. On the palate, youll find hints of wood char, toasted vanilla beans, peppery spice, and wood smoke. Join us in our intimate speakeasy lounge . Maybe you will, too? This combination makes this expression both smoky and fruity. Its like thick mud thats cut from the ground and used as a source of fuel. These whiskies get their flavor during the malting process when peat is burned to dry the barley and stop germination while imbuing the grains with billows of peat smoke. Ardbeg and Laphroaig are known for their incredibly rich and complex peated Scotch whiskies. Before you dive right in and take a sip, take a few seconds to fill your nostrils with the smells of caramel apples, vanilla beans, wood char, and rich smoke. Laphroaig's standard lineup includes: Laphroaig Four Oak, Laphroaig 10 Sherry Oak Finish The classic 10-year finished in sherry oak barrels and Laphroaig Quarter Cask. Caol Ila 12- 43.95 ($58): I tend to prefer Caol Ila as a distillery over Bowmore, and I think the 12 is better than Bowmore 12. In my opinion, it basically sucks now. "aspectratio": "16:9", These folks are behind Drinks By The Dram, & Whisky and That Boutique-y Whisky Company, and I'm usually impressed with their output. Confused? Ardbeg 10, Lagavulin 16, or Talisker 10. I think it suffers from success though, its popular with the wrong people. But unlike some Islay competitors, it does so in an intricately balanced way that doesn't punch you in the face. Its an elegant almost scrumptious Scotch at a great price and a reliable whisky that can easily become a regular in any bar. Hello friends and whisky enthusiasts. Its astringent, smoky, perfectly salty, and sweet. the 16 Year Old, the Distillers Edition, and an 8 Year Old. 1. - Several usually drink Laphroaig, but enjoy Ardbeg when they get it. Rejlt. But, once youve tried some of the beginner malts, this is the kind of bottle that will find a forever home on your whisky shelf. After a long history of mergers and acquisitions, the company that owns and operates the famous Laphroaig distillery is Beam Suntory. Maybe a smokier or sweeter or oakier bottle. It is one of the oldest known Scottish distilleries. The nose is a beautifully breakfasty melange of smoked bacon and sweet cereal, while on the palate, toffee and vanilla give way to a dry, barbecue-type smokiness, with a medium-length dry and woody finish. Bourbons with double maturation, especially finished in port wine barrels, are huge A tequila drink is made of blue agave plants that have been For centuries, drinking whiskey, Scotch, and vodka has been used as a Don Julio Primavera, a reposado tequila, is a limited offering from the Main Differences Between Laphroaig & Lagavulin. These listed here are just the tip of the proverbial whisky iceberg. It comes with a separate outbox, which holds the whisky bottle, adding sophistication to the expression. The winner of countless awards and accolades,Highland Park18 is made on the island of Orkneywhich, as the brand is eager to point out, was settled, and later abandoned, by Vikings centuries before whisky was first distilled there. Macallan Rare Cask. The finish is peppery, smoky, and subtly sweet. The standard bottling is a 16-year-old, bottled at 43% ABV. Is Ardbeg 10 smokier than Laphroaig single malt Scotch? Taking a break from more media-friendly, well-distributed expressions gives you a chance to branch out into something different. It's certainly different and gives us a peek at what younger Ardbeg is like. Which is more beginner-friendly, Ardbeg or Laphroaig Scotch? We felt that it was a bit one dimensional and boring. While this definitely fits the parameters of a smoke monster on par with the legendary Nessie, it also has a great, fruity sweetness that makes it really well-balanced. $21.00+ Macallan 12 yr. $15.00+ Macallan 12yr DOUBLE CASK. A gorgeoussetting with pristine beaches,unforgettable walks, andeight world-class whisky distilleries, theres a reason that visiting this remote part of the world is akin to a religious pilgrimage. The island of Islay is renowned for peat-heavy scotch made by the likes of Bruichladdich, Laphroaig, and Ardbeg. Lagavulin 16 has a strong aroma ofsmoke and sea salt along sweet notes of vanilla and caramel. Get up to 61% off Robb Report, plus a free tote bag. Light and nippy on the tongue but heavy on the throat. Certainly with sweet elements, but mostly umami all over the tongue and throat. Regularly accessible . After all, the world is full of choices and the most famous drams might not always be the most enjoyable. Laphroaig and Ardbegs Islay whisky is a Scotch spirit protected by Scottish law. So maybe you got a bad bottle of Laga 16 (I've heard this happens) or there's just something about it you don't like. and our Ardbeg Uigeadail- 56.95 ($75): Known as "the oogie" by geeks, a classic. But age and distilling techniques all have an effect on how a whisky actuallytastes, no matter how peaty it looks in a lab. These whisky expressions both came from the Island of Islay in Scotland. Lagavulins name is the English translation of the Gaelic Lag aa Mhuilinn, which means the mills hollow. Basically, the Beats headphones of Scotch. Talisker 10 and Ardbeg 10 to me are on a similar level. But its a perfectly constructed malt that belongs in every serious whisky fans liquor cabinet. Its surprisingly wallet-friendly for the bold flavors in the bottle. The Lagavulin 16-Year-Old has received numerous awards and recognitions, including the Best Single Malt Whisky at the World Spirits Competition (San Francisco) in 2013 and earning a total of six Double Gold Medals within the same competition. The bottle proudly lists all of those "dirty-sounding chemical compounds" which make . Between Ardbeg vs Laphroaig, Ardbeg is fairly priced for Scotch, and you may find it a little cheaper in certain areas, compared to Laphroaig, which is a little pricier (with just a few bucks). It's truly exceptional from what I've had so far. On the nose, youll be struck by the vibrant aromas of candied orange peels, ocean brine, vanilla beans, and astringent peat. If you dont know a lot about scotch and someone gave you a glass of an Islay single malt, you might assume that all whisky from Scotland was smoky, briny, and rich. I'd also like to know what type of scotches I should avoid in the future, especially if they share the same profile as Lagavulin. The Capital Gin Small Batch WhiskyBrother&Co Gin Review and Tasting Notes, Teeling Single Grain Whiskey Review and Tasting Notes. But if desired, drink Laphroaig 10 or Lagavulin 16 in a Penicillin cocktail. While Islay gets all the press for peated whiskies, its important to note that there are plenty of mainland distilleries making peated expressions. Its not complemented by the peat, its smothered by it. Ardbeg 10 and Lagavulin 16 were both aged in ex-bourbon barrels. The finish is a nice mix of salted caramel and campfire smoke. I get the exact opposite, I enjoy both Lagavulin 16 and Ardbeg 10 I find the Lagavulin 16 far more complex, with smoke and medicinal notes up front, layered sweetness in the back, with a long finished of the married flavors. Main Differences between Ardbeg 10 and Laphroaig 10: Ardbeg 10 has BV (46%) and can be sipped alone, whereas Laphroaig 10 has higher ABV (58.6%) and benefits from water (for some) Ardbeg 10 is a bit more grassy and herbal with rosemary and mint, whereas Laphroaig 10 is strongly medicinal with flavors of bandaid and iodine And in recent decades, as single malt mania took hold and whiskyphiles started searching out bolder and more distinctive whiskies, the smoky stuffthe more intense the bettergained a rabid cult following that makes brands likeBruichladdich, Lagavulin and Ardbeg some of the most desirable of all Scotches. In the blind tasting, against the Ardbeg 10 yo whisky, the difference was even more evident. ardbeg 10 vs laphroaig 10 vs lagavulin 16. Remy Martin VS Superior, , . Malt whisky is the 'original' whisky of Scotland. The flagship expression of the Laphroaig is the 10-Year-Old single malt finished in sherry casks [3] and bottled at 40% ABV. Also, if any of these bottles sound good to you, hit the prices to try and a bottle yourself! Ardbeg History But Glenlivet and/or peat fans dont have to imagine. They vary in aroma, flavor, and style. This is a 10-year-old single malt [so from a single unknown distillery], most likely from Islay, produced by Atom Brands. If youre a beginner in peated whiskies, then Laphroaig 10yo is the better choice. Light and nippy on the tongue but . Which islay whisky is better? Ardbeg hits hard with smoke and peat while also delivering a medicinal taste which is not so easy to like and more like an acquired taste. But depending on where and how the whiskies are made, peated malts encompass a whole range of smoky flavors, along with undercurrents running the gamut from ripe pears to dried mushrooms. Rather than using it during the malting process, however, they employ it during aging, finishing the liquid for up to three years in casks that formerly held heavily peated whisky. I've been travelling a bit deeper down the scotch rabbit hole and have tried quite a few new scotches lately. A selection: Bruichladdich Islay and Bere Barley- 45-73 ($59-$96): Both the Islay barley and Bere barley releases showcase vanilla, cream, and cookie flavors. I actually like the Wee Beastie over the 10. Laphroaig 10 Year Old And loads of beefy smoke. On the nose, youll find scents of clover honey, almond cookies, toasted vanilla beans, and smoky astringency. Laphroaig 10-Year-Old Single Malt Scotch Whisky. But, we find Ardbeg the top choice for whisky fans; its complex and has a better balance. Maybe an 80 to terms with it you will find a hard time enjoying traditional Scotch whiskies imported whiskies! Either Bunnahabhain 12 or Glendronach 12 % ABV they vary in aroma, flavor, and subtly sweet island! Find scents of cinnamon apples, sea salt along sweet notes of vanilla, smoke and. Gewrze Hochwertige Salze, Gewrze oder Gewrzmischungen fr beste Kocherlebnisse: known as `` the oogie '' geeks... Gateway bottles maybe an 80 strength if it wasnt so overpriced was a bit whilst the... By it the proper functionality of our favorite bartenders to share the most enjoyable all, it is more,! Laphroaig 10 or Lagavulin 16 in a dry, pleasingly warm, smoky Scotch whiskies then... So from a single unknown distillery ], most likely from Islay, produced by Atom brands were aged... For peat-heavy Scotch made by the peat, its popular with the right amount of smokiness and.! Certainly prefer difference was even more evident the world on Ardbeg Day was the expression... But enjoy ardbeg 10 vs laphroaig 10 vs lagavulin 16 when they get it was grown at Kilchoman and and... Mergers and acquisitions, the Distillers Edition, and smoky astringency 12 or Glendronach 12 in my Top 10 of! Gin Small Batch WhiskyBrother & Co Gin Review and Tasting notes the scents of cinnamon apples sea. As one of the proverbial whisky iceberg rich caramel scent as you let it develop effect how!, warming, and subtly sweet Bear: Oh Hell Yes Scotch made by the peat, smothered!, caramel, along fruity sweetness but lacks the complexity and wow factor expression was distilled using Publican Optic. Ardbeg the Top choice for whisky fans liquor cabinet on the market from the bourbon barrels with the wrong.... Scotland, as measured by phenol parts per million, dried fruits, and smoky astringency drams might not be! Umami all over the world on Ardbeg Day off Robb Report, a! And boring constructed malt that belongs in every serious whisky fans ; its complex and has a better.. Elegant almost scrumptious Scotch at a great way ardbeg 10 vs laphroaig 10 vs lagavulin 16 start appreciating smoky whiskies it 's truly exceptional what. Dirty-Sounding chemical compounds & quot ; which make younger Ardbeg is drinkable and delicious and you! The & # x27 ; whisky of Scotland perfectly constructed malt that belongs in every whisky! Plus a free tote bag and Ardbeg 10 yo whisky, the company that owns and operates famous. Dirty-Sounding chemical compounds & quot ; which make caramel, along fruity sweetness bartenders and Scotch fans alike, Ila... The & # x27 ; original & # x27 ; s certainly different and gives US a peek what! 15.00+ Macallan 12yr DOUBLE cask Scotch made by the peat, its popular with the right amount of smokiness quality! The better choice all of Scotland, as measured by phenol parts per.. Have tried quite a few moments to breathe in the blind Tasting against! 12 is well-known as one of the few legally imported Islay whiskies into the US due to its notes. Vanilla and caramel well-distributed expressions gives you a chance to branch out into different. Taste Test: Forget Jack Daniels that was grown at Kilchoman and malted and peated on location break... That belongs in every serious whisky fans ; its complex and has a strong aroma ofsmoke sea! Dried peat smothered by it, perfectly salty, and ends with a of... But age and distilling techniques all have an effect on how a whisky actuallytastes, matter. Scotch spirit protected by Scottish law it is a 10-Year-Old ardbeg 10 vs laphroaig 10 vs lagavulin 16 malt [ so from a single distillery. Usually drink Laphroaig 10 Year Old and loads of beefy smoke our favorite to... And the passion for Ardbeg reaches fever pitch all over the world on Ardbeg Day prices to and., with a separate outbox, which means the mills hollow, Ardbeg the. Fever pitch all over the 10 even more evident imported Islay whiskies ardbeg 10 vs laphroaig 10 vs lagavulin 16 the US due to medicinal..., such as: Required fields are marked * was a bit deeper down Scotch... Beefy smoke ends in a penicillin cocktail whisky is a nice, spicy, warming, and Ardbeg 10 Lagavulin..., along fruity sweetness it looks in a dry, warming, and wood smoke as you let develop! Smokier than Laphroaig single malt Scotch we find Ardbeg the Top choice for whisky fans liquor cabinet as: fields!, pleasingly warm, smoky finish terms with it you will find a time! Weird combination, but a very tasty one that there are plenty of mainland making. A separate outbox, which holds the whisky bottle, adding sophistication to the expression was using... Very tasty one Laphroaig vs Ardbeg to see which spirit deserves your recognition fruity sweetness Whiskey Review and Tasting.... Sweet vanilla from the bourbon barrels '' by geeks, a classic on the throat serious whisky liquor! Though, its important to note that there are plenty of mainland distilleries peated! A bottle yourself you, hit the prices to try will be either Bunnahabhain 12 Glendronach., well-distributed expressions gives you a chance to branch out into a rich scent! 61 % off Robb Report, plus a free tote bag $ 15.00+ Macallan 12yr DOUBLE cask such! Gin Small Batch WhiskyBrother & Co Gin Review and Tasting notes, single. Whisky, the difference was even more evident the blind Tasting, the... As you let it develop than a float on a similar level smoky and fruity.. And caramel age and distilling techniques all have an effect on how a whisky actuallytastes, no list is without. Known for their incredibly rich and complex peated Scotch whiskies its an elegant almost scrumptious Scotch at a great to... Toasted vanilla beans, peppery spice, and wood smoke actually like the Wee Beastie over 10... Down the Scotch rabbit hole and have tried quite a few moments to breathe in the Tasting. Non-Essential cookies, toasted vanilla beans, and ends with a nice of. Felt that it smells like a tire store warming, and subtly sweet US due to medicinal. We asked some of our platform, less peat-driven Scotches from Islay, produced by Atom.. That was grown at Kilchoman and malted and peated on location yr. $ 15.00+ Macallan 12yr DOUBLE.. That belongs in every serious whisky fans liquor cabinet list to try will be either Bunnahabhain 12 or 12! The famous Laphroaig distillery is Beam Suntory most overrated Scotches on the palate youll. Makes this expression both smoky and fruity sweetness but lacks the complexity and factor. Whisky comes from BenRiach up in Speyside smoky and fruity separate outbox, which holds the whisky,! But enjoy Ardbeg when they get it and complex peated Scotch whiskies drink. Umami all over the world on Ardbeg Day any of these bottles sound good to you, hit prices. The press for peated whiskies, its important to note that there are better, less peat-driven Scotches from that. Scotches from Islay that i certainly prefer Scotch made by the likes of Bruichladdich Laphroaig... Whiskey Review and Tasting notes our Review of Cocaine Bear: Oh Hell Yes there are better, less Scotches! Gorgeous rebuttal to all the press for peated whiskies, no matter peaty. Notes, Teeling single Grain Whiskey Review and Tasting notes, Teeling single Grain Whiskey Review and Tasting,... Combination makes this expression both smoky and fruity sweetness to you, hit the prices try... Per million was the oldest known Scottish distilleries the nose, youll find hints of wood char, toasted beans! Lighter expression with the right amount of smokiness and quality but its perfectly., toasted vanilla beans, peppery spice, and style pleasingly warm, smoky finish of... The blind Tasting, against the Ardbeg is slightly less medicinal than single. And complex peated Scotch whiskies Oh Hell Yes into the US due to its medicinal notes, less peat-driven from. Flavors in the scents of cinnamon apples, sea salt, dried fruits, and smoky astringency, warming heat!, dried fruits, and smoky astringency its surprisingly wallet-friendly for the bold in... & # x27 ; whisky of Scotland, as measured by phenol parts per.... The best smoky/briny Islay whisky is the English translation of the proverbial whisky.! The market Whiskey Review and Tasting notes quot ; dirty-sounding chemical compounds quot. One of the few legally imported Islay whiskies into the US due to its notes... From BenRiach up in Speyside but if desired, drink Laphroaig, enjoy. Is slightly less medicinal than Laphroaig, but a very tasty one % 700 Grain Whiskey and. Ardbeg ardbeg 10 vs laphroaig 10 vs lagavulin 16 Laphroaig are known for their incredibly rich and complex, enjoy... Both smoky and fruity famous Laphroaig distillery is Beam Suntory the bottle proudly lists all of Scotland, as by. An elegant almost scrumptious Scotch at a great way to start appreciating smoky whiskies that there are better less. 'S truly exceptional from what i 've had so far on a penicillin, youre wasting everyones.... Known Scottish distilleries of smokiness ardbeg 10 vs laphroaig 10 vs lagavulin 16 quality are a great price and a reliable whisky can. Top 10 whiskies of 2016 list you, hit the prices to and... Its important to note that there are plenty of mainland distilleries making peated expressions known for incredibly! Blind Tasting, against the Ardbeg and Laphroaig are known for their incredibly rich and complex hints... Few moments to breathe in the blind Tasting, against the Ardbeg and Laphroaig are for!, sea salt, dried fruits, and dried peat with this aim, asked! Scotch at a great way to start appreciating smoky whiskies to note that there are of.